Connect with us

Real Estate News

Can 1, 2, 3, and 4 Bhks in one complex cause societal conflicts?

Published

on

Can 1, 2, 3, and 4 Bhks in one complex cause societal conflicts?

When 35-year-old Nimesh Shah (name changed) bought a 3BHK apartment in a premium housing society in Mumbai’s outskirts, he thought he’d finally found an aspirational location in the city’s increasingly costly real estate market.

Shah, who earns around ₹6 lakh per month, purchased a unit in a luxury residential tower with 4 and 5 BHK apartments. However, immediately after taking ownership, he found that affording the apartment was only one side of the problem; meeting society’s lifestyle expectations was a very different challenge.

The turning point occurred when inhabitants of the building advocated remodelling the lobby interiors because they were dissatisfied with the current aesthetics. Homeowners were requested to contribute from their own pockets to the improvement.

Shah, who already pays an EMI of almost ₹2.75 lakh per month and spends another ₹2 lakh to ₹2.5 lakh on domestic and leisure costs, found the demand financially challenging. “I suddenly felt trapped, and even a single unexpected societal expense started feeling stressful because most of my income was already committed,” he stated.

Shah’s story exemplifies a rising worry in luxury township projects and premium gated communities in Mumbai, Pune, and Bengaluru: the financial disparity between inhabitants living in the smallest flats and others who own much larger residences within the same complex. While developers in township projects may provide a variety of 2, 3, 4, and 5BHK layouts to appeal to a broader range of homebuyers, the social and financial dynamics of such communities can sometimes put pressure on buyers at the lower end of the project’s pricing spectrum.

According to real estate advisors, in many luxury societies, discretionary expenditure on aesthetics, amenities, events, and upgrades is frequently driven by inhabitants of larger units who have far more spare income. Despite having relatively good wages on paper, homebuyers who strained their finances to enter a premium location may find it difficult to bear these recurring payments over time.

Why is the discussion over diversified unit sizes in housing societies gaining traction right now?

The argument recently resurfaced online after a viral Reddit post from a housing society in Karnataka claimed that occupants of 1 BHK and 1 RK apartments were denied access to amenities such as the gym and swimming pool despite paying maintenance fees. The article sparked extensive debate about class disparities, unequal access to facilities, and conflict between occupants of tiny and large homes.

According to one tenant, the society has implemented regulations that prevent occupants of smaller flats from utilizing communal amenities, despite the fact that maintenance is paid for by all residents.

“In developments with varying apartment sizes, residents frequently contribute different maintenance amounts and have diverse spending capabilities. According to Dipesh Joshi, a Mumbai-based real estate consultant, decisions such as clubhouse usage, parking allocation, and sinking funds can lead to social divisions. For example, Nimesh Shah, who lived in South Mumbai, sold his smaller apartment to purchase a larger one in a semi-luxury township in the suburbs. However, after a year in the new house, he realized it was unsustainable in the long run. The reason for this was because inhabitants of 4- and 5-BHK apartments held opposing views to those of 3-BHK units, resulting in disagreements over day-to-day maintenance and funding. Finally, when Shah approached me, I suggested he sell the apartment and buy one in a nearby development. However, downgrading is not an easy option,” Joshi added.

What do developers have to say about product mix?

According to real estate developers, township projects in places such as Pune and Bengaluru have a more diverse product mix. “We have township developments in Pune and Bengaluru where developers are selling 1, 2, 3, and 4 BHK apartments in various structures within the township. However, there is barely such a product mix in Mumbai,” said a developer who did not want to be named. “We have projects offering 1 and 2 BHK, 2, 3 BHK, or 3, 4, 5 BHK.” This is the product mix, and it is also a safe combination for making ventures viable. One cause for Mumbai’s lack of product combinations is a lack of available land. As a result, developers have a very sharp and targeted product mix to ensure they don’t make mistakes,” the developer explained.

Another well-known developer noted, “In Mumbai, development control regulations generally do not restrict a residential project’s apartment mix, allowing developers to offer 1-5 BHKs in one society.”

The developer stated, “However, restrictions primarily arise in special schemes such as MHADA, SRA, or redevelopment projects with rehab or affordable housing obligations.” In practice, product mix is mostly determined by economics, FSI efficiency, parking regulations, and market demand.” 

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Real Estate News

MHADA Flags 82 Mumbai Buildings as ‘Most Dangerous’; Residents Told to Vacate

Published

on

MHADA Flags 82 Mumbai Buildings as ‘Most Dangerous’; Residents Told to Vacate

Before the monsoon, the Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority (MHADA)’s Mumbai Building Repairs and Reconstruction Board (MBRRB) issued a list of 82 residential buildings in South and Central Mumbai that have been designated as the city’s most dangerous structures and must be evacuated immediately.

After completing the pre-monsoon survey report, the MHADA ordered inhabitants to evacuate these structures.

According to MHADA, the list of 82 buildings includes 43 buildings that were designated severely unsafe last year. The BMC is yet to release its list of dilapidated properties in the city this year.

In 2025, the MHADA issued a list of 96 severely risky structures. Separately, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) identified 134 more old structures across the city for 2025 and has given urgent eviction warnings to tenants.

In 2024, MHADA produced a similar list of 20 severely unsafe buildings, while BMC issued a list of 188 decaying structures throughout the city.

What is the MHADA’s pre-monsoon audit?

Every year, prior to the monsoon, the MHADA conducts a structural examination to identify structures that pose a safety risk. Based on the findings, MHADA sends evacuation notifications to residents of structures deemed ‘hazardous’.

To help affected residents, MHADA provides transit tenements in different sites. However, many occupants refuse to relocate owing to location preferences, neighborhood ties, and other social issues. Redevelopment of such decrepit structures has long been an issue in Mumbai’s real estate sector, with numerous building collapses reported during the monsoon season.

Where are the 82 most dangerous buildings located?

According to the MHADA, the 82 most unsafe buildings are located in Girgaum, Kalbadevi, Kamathipura, Khetwadi, Mazgaon, Dadar, and Prabhadevi, among others. There are 2,736 renters in these 82 high-risk properties.

“These severely unsafe cessed structures house a total of 2,736 tenants/residents, with 2,256 being residential and 480 being non-residential. The Board has served notices to 176 residential residents, requiring them to remove their properties. According to the announcement, 29 residential tenants/residents have been transferred to MHADA transit camps, while 36 have made alternate arrangements for their lodging.

According to MHADA, the Board is making the required measures to accommodate 2,102 tenants/residents in transit camps. “As required, notices to vacate will be issued to residents/tenants of these highly dangerous buildings and further arrangements for their relocation to transit camps will be made accordingly,” the MHADA stated in its statement.

In its statement, MHADA urged renters and inhabitants of highly unsafe buildings to comply with officials and personnel in fleeing the premises when needed, as well as to follow any directions issued for their personal and their family members’ safety, in order to avoid loss of life and property.

Continue Reading

Real Estate News

Mumbai Redevelopment Boom Continues Into 2026

Published

on

Mumbai Redevelopment Boom Continues Into 2026

Mumbai’s real estate rehabilitation market gained 16% in 2025 over the previous year, owing to an increase in redevelopment deals around the city. According to Knight Frank India, a total of 229 development agreements (DAs) for the renovation of ancient structures were signed in 2025, up from 196 the previous year.

The enthusiasm carried over into 2026, with roughly 30%, or 70, of the total redevelopment agreements for 2025 inked in the first 74 days of the year, up to March 15, according to the data.

Total of 1,094 DAs signed in the last 6 years

According to Knight Frank India data, 1,094 DAs have been signed during the last six years, from January 2020 to March 15, 2026. The signature of these 1,094 redevelopment accords has made 432 acres of land available for redevelopment.

Western suburbs have the biggest amount of redevelopment transactions.

The western suburbs of Mumbai’s real estate market have signed the most redevelopment agreements during the last six years. According to the data, 773 of the 1,094 DAs signed were in the western suburbs, unlocking 321.2 acres of land, followed by 261 in the central suburbs, unlocking 85.9 acres of land, 38 in Central Mumbai, unlocking 38 acres of land, and 22 in South Mumbai, unlocking 8.3 acres of land.

Borivali leads with 20% of the total redevelopment deals

Out of the total 1,094 DAs signed, Borivali in Mumbai’s western suburbs had the most (217), unlocking 90.4 acres of land, followed by Andheri (115), unlocking 74.8 acres.

Bandra had the third-highest number of 74 DAs signed, unlocking 24.4 acres of land, followed by Malad with 67 DAs signed, unlocking 26.6 acres of land, and Ghatkopar with the fifth-highest number of 59 DAs signed, unlocking 14.1 acres of land for redevelopment.

Old building redevelopment to add 59,000 units

According to the data, the signing of about 1,100 DAs has resulted in the creation of 59,000 housing units, with over 45,000 to be developed in the western suburbs, over 11,800 in the central suburbs, over 1,600 in Central Mumbai, and 731 in South Mumbai.

Knight Frank India did a unit generation analysis using the Floor Space Index (FSI) for sale areas; rehab and amenity spaces were excluded. The data show that the unit generation estimate is primarily dependent on supply and does not account for launch velocity, funding, or phasing constraints.

According to the research, the redevelopment projects will create 1.5 lakh housing units and produce ₹9,115 crore in stamp duty revenue for the state government.

FSI norms for redevelopment

According to Knight Frank India, most societal redevelopment projects are now being carried out under the Development Control Regulation (DCR) 33(9), 33(11), and 33(20b). These laws set the maximum Floor Space Index (FSI) for redevelopment. The available FSI is determined by the width of the road adjoining the housing society.

Continue Reading

Real Estate News

MHADA Lottery 2026 Draws 78,000+ Applications for 2,640 Homes

Published

on

MHADA Lottery 2026 Draws 78,000+ Applications for 2,640 Homes

The Maharashtra Housing and Development Authority (MHADA) lottery 2026 has received over 78,000 applications in nearly two months since it announced the housing draw for 2,640 affordable homes in Mumbai’s real estate market.

According to MHADA data, the housing authority received 78,976 applications for 2,640 flats through May 18, 2026. Furthermore, the state housing administration has received 55,244 Earnest Money Deposits (EMDs) from applicants looking to buy an apartment.

Last date to apply for MHADA lottery 2026 has been extended.

According to the updated schedule released by the Mumbai Board, interested applicants can submit online applications until 11:59 p.m. on May 28, 2026, and pay the earnest money deposit online until 11:59 p.m. on May 29, 2026. Applicants may also pay the earnest money deposit via RTGS/NEFT till the working hours of the relevant bank on May 29, 2026.

The provisional list of lottery applications submitted will thereafter be published on the website https://housing.mhada.gov.in at 3:00 p.m. on June 10, 2026. Online claims and objections can be submitted until 3:00 p.m. on June 12, 2026. The final list of accepted applications will be posted on the MHADA website at 3:00 p.m. on June 16, 2026. The date, location, and time of the computerized draw for the sale of tenements will be announced on the website shortly.

Apart from extending the deadline for applications twice, the MHADA has also decreased the price of nearly half of the flats. The MHADA has lowered the sale cost of 1,221 tenements in Mumbai’s Vikhroli neighborhood by 7.5%, including 610 apartments whose category reservation was changed last week from MIG to HIG.

MHADA Lottery 2026 Apartment Prices

The MHADA lottery 2026 has listed 2,640 affordable homes for sale in Mumbai. According to data from the MHADA website, 1,762 flats, or approximately 66%, are now under construction.

MHADA apartments for sale are now under construction in Vikhroli, Goregaon, and Borivali. According to the list, of the 1,762 flats under construction, 128 are in Borivali East, 85 in Goregaon West, and the rest in Kanamwar Nagar and Vikhroli.

Several apartments in the lottery cost between ₹2 crore and ₹4 crore. The list shows that the most inexpensive flats are above 300 sq ft in Mankhurd and Goregaon, priced at around ₹29 lakh and ₹32 lakh, respectively.

The MHADA Lottery 2026 features apartments in numerous Mumbai neighborhoods, including Vikhroli, Goregaon, Borivali, Gorai, Chembur, Bandra, Ghatkopar, Wadala, Powai, and Dadar, among others.

MHADA’s most expensive apartment is in the Tardeo region of South Mumbai, priced at ₹6.82 crore for the High Income Group (HIG). The most inexpensive property for sale by MHADA is in Mankhurd, priced at about ₹29 lakh for the Economically Weaker Section.

Continue Reading

Trending